Directed by: Omung
Kumar
Starring: Priyanka
Chopra, Darshan Kumaar, Sunil Thapa
Released: 2014
My rating: destroy
every copy – horrible – bad – whatever – flawed
but enjoyable - good – great –
amazing
– experience
Before I even start with
the film itself, I think I need to explain one thing: I hate boxing.
I do not consider it a sport of civilized people, for it lacks what I
am looking for in a sport event – team spirit or an individual
stepping over one´s limits. The sole purpose of box is to simply
beat the shit out of the other and you cannot tell me otherwise. That
much said I have nothing but respect for Mary Kom as a woman who had
to go through struggles which would weary out majority of other
people (including me). In that aspect her life story is immensely
inspirational and should be told. Just perhaps not the way this
particular film does it.
Even without not being
intimately familiar with the life of Mary Kom, all its twists and
turns, I dare say it was dramatic enough to be an intriguing picture,
however the filmmakers felt the need to ad lots and lots of filmi
clichés, which they hoped would enhance the major points of the
narrative, unfortunately they reach an absolutely opposite effect.
They strike out of nowhere and leave one slightly baffled or dubious,
they seem too improbable and made-up – basically they do not go
with the rest of the film. The most prominent among these are scenes
which show Mary in sort of mystical, mental contact with her father
and later one of her baby sons, which directly influences her ability
to fight. While common in fictional films, I cannot help but wonder
if this bit was necessary in a biopic. The songs, too, were not
needed and only diluted the story. The “villain” shares the over
the top sheer nastiness reminding one of all those negative roles by
Prakash Raj, and again, lacks the believable factor.
The film belongs to
Priyanka Chopra. It is not her best ever performance and I still
think she was a miscast. It was ironic seeing her accusing the match
jury of racism, when her casting itself could be called racist. I am
not saying I am a great know-it-all on the issue, but I still recall
the reasoning of the makers, who stated they knowingly cast Priyanka
because a new, Manipuri actress, would not be bankable. What was the
intention then? To tell a story of a Manipuri woman who beat every
obstacle INCLUDING negative, dismissive attitude so many have against
people who look like her, or to make a bankable film? Because they
did not manage to have both. I am aware Mary Kom herself was
satisfied with the movie, but I do not believe her consent was the
best thing to have happened to her community, which so rarely gets
the deserved attention and representation in media. This was an
opportunity which nobody took. That much said, Priyanka deserves
heaps of credit for her incredible dedication. One can see she put
her heart and soul into the role, not fearing the physical demands. I
suppose much like I respect Mary but disagree with boxing I also
respect Priyanka but disagree with her being the protagonist. I
salute their work and dedication – and success.
Looking back the at “big”
biopic of the last year, Bhaag Milkha Bhaag, Mary Kom fails to leave
a mark. Where Bhaag Milkha managed to deal with the athlete´s
haunted conscience, his inner struggle and issues, while at the same
time being a good sports film, Mary Kom is a good sports-film, but
the backstory is really just... a backstory. Why did Mary picked up
that glove in the beginning? Why did she love box but disliked
athletics? How did she feel when she started a family? We do get to
see most of what happened, but hardly any of the scenes really
touches the inner conflicts which must have plagued Mary once. And
since the main protagonist is left without more complex feelings (as
a film character, I am not saying the REAL Mary Kom does not have
complex feelings!), you cannot expect more from other characters
either. In case of Onler, Mary Kom´s husband, that made me almost
sad. (if he is in real life the half man he was shown to be on
screen, he is everything a woman could ever want!).
Mary Kom the film is not
as magnificent as its subject, but it could be treated as a good way
of getting some really basic knowledge on her. Decent, but less than
what it could have been and deserved to have become.
I didn't have any high hopes for this movie. I thought, it was gonna be another average flick. Bollywood is totally unpredictable though. Lets wait and watch what more it has to offer.
ReplyDeleteRegards,
Kunik Goel