Directed by: Guru Dutt
Starring: Guru Dutt, Waheeda Rehman,
Johnny Walker
Released: 1959
Verdict: destroy every
copy – horrible – bad – whatever – flawed but enjoyable -
good – great – amazing
This is what stirs the
heart. This is what deserves to be called epic. This is what amazing
films should be like. And nobody can convince me now, that Guru Dutt
is not the greatest of all Bollywood directors ever. And a wonderful
actor too. Kaagaz Ke Phool is a story about a man who looses
everything, and gets to a point in life, when he even knowingly
refuses what he desires most, because his spirit is all but spent and
he feels he has nothing to give in return. Many argue that Kaagaz Ke
Phool was to Guru Dutt what Mera Naam Joker was later to Raj Kapoor –
an autobiography of sorts, a confession of inner feelings. But while
Raj Kapoor opted to become a „joker“ on screen for his magnum
opus, Guru Dutt chose his film to be set – in film studios and
„behind the scenes“. A film with similar concept – of unveiling
the mysterious (at that time) world of film studios and filmmakers,
was Guddi, but in comparism Guddi was a light-hearted picture about a girl who needs to sort out reality and fantasy, while Kaagaz Ke Phool
is like a mirror of somebody´s soul, of the most intimate feelings
and beautiful in all its sadness – all of which are chief
characteristics of Guru Dutt movies after all.
In a one huge flashback we
are told the story of Suresh Sinha (Guru Dutt), an extremely
successful and critically acclaimed director, who has wonderful
career, but highly unsatisfactory personal life. He is married, but
his wife has left him after he joined the film industry, faithful to
the idea of the time that all people connected with films are
despicable, low and „dirty“ creatures. More than his wife however
Suresh is missing his teen daughter Pammi, whom his wife is trying to
keep away from him. After yet another failed attempt to bring his
daughter with him to Mumbai, he (yet again) tries to find solace in
his work. But not even that seems to be working, because he cannot
find an actress to portray Paro in his „Devdas“. Until one day a
girl as fresh as a flower and as different from fashionable glamour
divas of silver screen as possible, awkwardly appears right in from
of his camera by mistake, clutching a coat he had given her not long
ago, when they met during a stormy night, seeking shelter under a
tree....
Guru Dutt as a performer was extremely natural. I don´t think that apart from him and Dilip Kumar there has been an actor who would need so little words and expression and yet manage to convey perfectly what the character is going through. He also gives you a feeling there is so much more, still more of that pain and questioning the world, than what is shown through the scenes and dialogues – and songs, that are beautiful and full of beautiful melancholy. Somehow one is not capable of just walking away from the film, even though it is, in a way, quite depressing. Finally one has to wonder how much of his personal life really found place in the script. The thought of him predicting his own premature and lonely death is chilling, even though I am inclined to believe it was all just a very sad coincidence. At the same time, the storyline about Suresh and Shanti, may very well be a heartfelt confession....
Shanti, a girl already
mentioned, that girl who wants nothing but to return a coat, but is
made waiting during the shoot, which she delightfully yawns through,
is played by Waheeda Rehman. Waheeda Rehman, whom Guru Dutt called
his inspiration, and who unquestionably belongs among the most
graceful, gorgeous and talented actresses of India ever (I am not
discussing this with anyone). One could stare at her forever. Hers is
a beauty that touches the inner you, that comes straight to your
heart. She can move you to tears just by being on screen, her gentle
and yet overpowering presence is extraordinary. Her pairing with Guru
Dutt is nothing short of perfect. It is as if they were meant to be.
That is all you know watching them. A few softly spoken words,
several fleeting touches. And that is all. And yet you know that this
is Love happening in front of your eyes. It is no secret after all,
that they loved each other in real life as well. Unhappy in his
marriage , and feeling misunderstood by everyone (just like the
character of Suresh) he found comfort in the young actress, who loved
him in return, never exploiting his position in the industry for her
own goals, not using him as a stepping stone to secure her own
future.
Love is the backbone of the movie, but there is still enough space to other issues to be touched as well. The ungratefulness of the world, the hyenism of the machine that is film industry, the disdain with which some people even today look upon cinema, even emotional turmoil of a child whose parents do not live together. Emotional blackmailing and voluntarily fall of grace too have place in this story. The excellent camera work and lighting of the film are not made justice by new DVD prints, that rarely are of good quality. Time was not kind to the film reels that Guru Dutt once presented to the world.
Kaagaz Ke Phool is no paper flower which looks beautiful but has nothing else to offer but a shallow, short-lived infatuation before the colours fade. It is a most beautiful rose with soft petals of vibrant tones, blooming eternally.
Hello,
ReplyDeleteYou write very beautifully: "Kaagaz Ke Phool is like a mirror of somebody´s soul", and I'd say this comment is certainly as apt as ever in this great movie.
Another very well written line: "He also gives you a feeling there is so much more, still more of that pain and questioning the world, than what is shown through the scenes and dialogues – and songs, that are beautiful and full of beautiful melancholy"
Thanks!
My "thank you! for a lovely comment!
Delete